Sarna News: Bad 'Mechs - Icestorm

Editing Hero 'Mech

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 15: Line 15:
  
 
==Canonicity==
 
==Canonicity==
The convoluted canon status of individual Hero 'Mechs is best understood by considering a "Hero 'Mech" to be a composite concept consisting of its name, appearance, configuration, and fluff (background lore). Each of these aspects should be considered separately, and may be [[canonical]], [[apocryphal]], or outright noncanon.
+
The convoluted canon status of individual Hero 'Mechs is best understood by considering a "Hero 'Mech" to be a composite concept consisting of its name, appearance, configuration, and fluff (background lore). Each of these aspects should be considered separately, and may be [[canon]]ical, [[apocryphal]], or outright noncanon.
  
 
To begin with, most (but not all) Hero 'Mechs are based on an individual 'Mech mentioned in a canonical source, usually a ''Technical Readout'' sourcebook. They are obviously canonical to the extent mentioned in canon.
 
To begin with, most (but not all) Hero 'Mechs are based on an individual 'Mech mentioned in a canonical source, usually a ''Technical Readout'' sourcebook. They are obviously canonical to the extent mentioned in canon.
Line 21: Line 21:
 
PGI derives its BattleTech license from the license for BattleTech computer games which is currently owned by Microsoft and is a separate license from the mainline BattleTech boardgame IP that is currently owned by [[Topps]], and licensed to CGL. For the purpose of Canon, Sarna BattleTechWiki considers only the boardgame IP to be authoritative. As such, content from computer games is not considered canonical per se, but apocryphal by default. This applies to any and all information about Hero 'Mechs that was created by PGI, as opposed to originating in canonical BattleTech lore.
 
PGI derives its BattleTech license from the license for BattleTech computer games which is currently owned by Microsoft and is a separate license from the mainline BattleTech boardgame IP that is currently owned by [[Topps]], and licensed to CGL. For the purpose of Canon, Sarna BattleTechWiki considers only the boardgame IP to be authoritative. As such, content from computer games is not considered canonical per se, but apocryphal by default. This applies to any and all information about Hero 'Mechs that was created by PGI, as opposed to originating in canonical BattleTech lore.
  
However, the descriptive fluff texts for the Hero 'Mechs have been declared fully canonical for the BattleTech universe by then-incumbent [[Catalyst Game Labs]] [[Line Developer]], [[Randall N. Bills]], who also penned most if not all of these texts. That means by extension that the 'Mechs as such are canon even when not otherwise mentioned in BattleTech lore, but only to the extent described in the accompanying fluff text. By contrast, their in-game stats and appearance are still [[apocryphal]] unless mentioned in the fluff text; and in case of clashes with established BattleTech lore such as anachronistic equipment they are overruled by the established canon, making the overruled parts noncanonical.<br />(With the release of ''[[BattleTech: Legends]]'' a number of unique names first introduced in MWO were used, though with configurations and equipment that do not match their MWO counterparts.)
+
However, the descriptive fluff texts for the Hero 'Mechs have been declared fully [[canon]]ical for the BattleTech universe by then-incumbent [[Catalyst Game Labs]] [[Line Developer]], [[Randall N. Bills]], who also penned most if not all of these texts. That means by extension that the 'Mechs as such are canon even when not otherwise mentioned in BattleTech lore, but only to the extent described in the accompanying fluff text. By contrast, their in-game stats and appearance are still [[apocryphal]] unless mentioned in the fluff text; and in case of clashes with established BattleTech lore such as anachronistic equipment they are overruled by the established canon, making the overruled parts noncanonical.<br />(With the release of ''[[BattleTech: Legends]]'' a number of unique names first introduced in MWO were used, though with configurations and equipment that do not match their MWO counterparts.)
  
 
Complicating things further, there is an exception to Randall Bills' ruling: MWO has since published several original 'Mech designs, and Hero 'Mechs were created and fluffed for these as well. Assistant Line Developer [[Ray "Adrian Gideon" Arrastia]] expressly clarified that the original designs from PGI are not canonical,<ref>In [https://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=63650.msg1464943#msg1464943 this] posting on the official [[BattleTech Forum]] by Ray "Adrian Gideon" Arrastia, regarding the canon status of PGI-exclusive 'Mechs for which [[record sheet]]s had been brought to [[Mech_Con 2018]]: "''Those sheets are not official and those designs are not canon for the tabletop. CGL cannot use the PGI-created designs, no matter what “part” CGL or its employees play in the creation of the designs. When asked for confirmation, Randall and Brent stated that those were provided by a demo agent and they allowed it *this time only* as part of the hype at [[Mech_Con]].''"</ref> regardless of any Hero 'Mechs or Hero 'Mech fluff associated with them.
 
Complicating things further, there is an exception to Randall Bills' ruling: MWO has since published several original 'Mech designs, and Hero 'Mechs were created and fluffed for these as well. Assistant Line Developer [[Ray "Adrian Gideon" Arrastia]] expressly clarified that the original designs from PGI are not canonical,<ref>In [https://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=63650.msg1464943#msg1464943 this] posting on the official [[BattleTech Forum]] by Ray "Adrian Gideon" Arrastia, regarding the canon status of PGI-exclusive 'Mechs for which [[record sheet]]s had been brought to [[Mech_Con 2018]]: "''Those sheets are not official and those designs are not canon for the tabletop. CGL cannot use the PGI-created designs, no matter what “part” CGL or its employees play in the creation of the designs. When asked for confirmation, Randall and Brent stated that those were provided by a demo agent and they allowed it *this time only* as part of the hype at [[Mech_Con]].''"</ref> regardless of any Hero 'Mechs or Hero 'Mech fluff associated with them.

Please note that all contributions to BattleTechWiki are considered to be released under the GNU FDL 1.2 (see BattleTechWiki:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To edit this page, please answer the question that appears below (more info):

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)

Advanced templates:

Editing: {{Merge}}   {{Moratorium}}   {{Otheruses| | | }}

Notices: {{NoEdit}}   {{Sign}}   {{Unsigned|name}}   {{Welcome}}

Administration: {{Essay}}   {{Policy}}   {{Procedure}}