Editing BattleTechWiki:Requests for comment/Completed Requests
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
The edit can be undone.
Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision
Your text
Line 1,130:
Line 1,130: :::::I think it's good to add relevant information to articles, even if that information is on a different article (except in certain circumstances). In this specific instance, I think adding the production location of specific variants of military vehicles is a good addition. I have had a couple of concerns about this that I have raised with Neuling in the past. First, be certain that the information is supported by canon information; sometimes it can be tempting to add something for the sake of completeness, but we have to be certain that the information is stated somewhere rather than creating our own conclusions (for example, there may be no information about where a specific variant is produced; it can be tempting to state that the variant is produced at the same place as the standard model, but this may not be the case). Second, I would prefer to see the information integrated into existing sections, as with the above example of the ''Lightning'', rather than creating an entirely new section for it. Did I miss anything? --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 00:22, 4 December 2011 (UTC) :::::I think it's good to add relevant information to articles, even if that information is on a different article (except in certain circumstances). In this specific instance, I think adding the production location of specific variants of military vehicles is a good addition. I have had a couple of concerns about this that I have raised with Neuling in the past. First, be certain that the information is supported by canon information; sometimes it can be tempting to add something for the sake of completeness, but we have to be certain that the information is stated somewhere rather than creating our own conclusions (for example, there may be no information about where a specific variant is produced; it can be tempting to state that the variant is produced at the same place as the standard model, but this may not be the case). Second, I would prefer to see the information integrated into existing sections, as with the above example of the ''Lightning'', rather than creating an entirely new section for it. Did I miss anything? --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 00:22, 4 December 2011 (UTC) ::::::Hy good catch, but i give you this example, we don't need it on some BattleMech, Combat Vehicles pages, we have the [[Heavy Tracked APC]] page, in the infobox we add the manufacturer, at this example [[Quikscell Company]] he is added on the vehicle page, you go to it and found the vehicle is produced on [[Ares (planet)|Ares]], you hit the Ares link then you come to the planet page and se Ares is a Capellan Confederation planet and was produced on it, i don't want merged content on the 'Mech, Combat Vehicle sites that don't follow the Project Template. Neuling have good ideas but the problem is, he don't follow any policy, project or ref. policies and follow the right formating, take a look on [[Wars of Reaving - Timeline]], iam really sadly to say this, i don't fix or correct any contributions that he provide in next or future time, iam to tired, i talke to often to the problem, he is as a long time contributor (circa 1-2 year) on sarna and don't follow anything, this is my opinion, please talk to me when iam wrong.--[[User:Doneve|Doneve]] 01:16, 4 December 2011 (UTC) ::::::Hy good catch, but i give you this example, we don't need it on some BattleMech, Combat Vehicles pages, we have the [[Heavy Tracked APC]] page, in the infobox we add the manufacturer, at this example [[Quikscell Company]] he is added on the vehicle page, you go to it and found the vehicle is produced on [[Ares (planet)|Ares]], you hit the Ares link then you come to the planet page and se Ares is a Capellan Confederation planet and was produced on it, i don't want merged content on the 'Mech, Combat Vehicle sites that don't follow the Project Template. Neuling have good ideas but the problem is, he don't follow any policy, project or ref. policies and follow the right formating, take a look on [[Wars of Reaving - Timeline]], iam really sadly to say this, i don't fix or correct any contributions that he provide in next or future time, iam to tired, i talke to often to the problem, he is as a long time contributor (circa 1-2 year) on sarna and don't follow anything, this is my opinion, please talk to me when iam wrong.--[[User:Doneve|Doneve]] 01:16, 4 December 2011 (UTC) − : Neuling - Respectfully, some of your changes might be more agreeable if they were "cleaner". Specifically, if there weren't so many typos. Both Doneve and I have had to cleanup the [[Lightning (Aerospace Fighter class)|Lightning]]. Thanks. [[User:ClanWolverine101|ClanWolverine101]] 07:39, 5 December 2011 (UTC) + : Neuling - Respectfully, some of your changes might be more agreeable if they were "cleaner". Specifically, if there weren't so many typos. Both Doneve and I have had to cleanup the [[Lightning]]. Thanks. [[User:ClanWolverine101|ClanWolverine101]] 07:39, 5 December 2011 (UTC) ===MechWarrior Online=== ===MechWarrior Online===
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 1,130: | Line 1,130: | ||
:::::I think it's good to add relevant information to articles, even if that information is on a different article (except in certain circumstances). In this specific instance, I think adding the production location of specific variants of military vehicles is a good addition. I have had a couple of concerns about this that I have raised with Neuling in the past. First, be certain that the information is supported by canon information; sometimes it can be tempting to add something for the sake of completeness, but we have to be certain that the information is stated somewhere rather than creating our own conclusions (for example, there may be no information about where a specific variant is produced; it can be tempting to state that the variant is produced at the same place as the standard model, but this may not be the case). Second, I would prefer to see the information integrated into existing sections, as with the above example of the ''Lightning'', rather than creating an entirely new section for it. Did I miss anything? --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 00:22, 4 December 2011 (UTC) | :::::I think it's good to add relevant information to articles, even if that information is on a different article (except in certain circumstances). In this specific instance, I think adding the production location of specific variants of military vehicles is a good addition. I have had a couple of concerns about this that I have raised with Neuling in the past. First, be certain that the information is supported by canon information; sometimes it can be tempting to add something for the sake of completeness, but we have to be certain that the information is stated somewhere rather than creating our own conclusions (for example, there may be no information about where a specific variant is produced; it can be tempting to state that the variant is produced at the same place as the standard model, but this may not be the case). Second, I would prefer to see the information integrated into existing sections, as with the above example of the ''Lightning'', rather than creating an entirely new section for it. Did I miss anything? --[[User:Scaletail|Scaletail]] 00:22, 4 December 2011 (UTC) | ||
::::::Hy good catch, but i give you this example, we don't need it on some BattleMech, Combat Vehicles pages, we have the [[Heavy Tracked APC]] page, in the infobox we add the manufacturer, at this example [[Quikscell Company]] he is added on the vehicle page, you go to it and found the vehicle is produced on [[Ares (planet)|Ares]], you hit the Ares link then you come to the planet page and se Ares is a Capellan Confederation planet and was produced on it, i don't want merged content on the 'Mech, Combat Vehicle sites that don't follow the Project Template. Neuling have good ideas but the problem is, he don't follow any policy, project or ref. policies and follow the right formating, take a look on [[Wars of Reaving - Timeline]], iam really sadly to say this, i don't fix or correct any contributions that he provide in next or future time, iam to tired, i talke to often to the problem, he is as a long time contributor (circa 1-2 year) on sarna and don't follow anything, this is my opinion, please talk to me when iam wrong.--[[User:Doneve|Doneve]] 01:16, 4 December 2011 (UTC) | ::::::Hy good catch, but i give you this example, we don't need it on some BattleMech, Combat Vehicles pages, we have the [[Heavy Tracked APC]] page, in the infobox we add the manufacturer, at this example [[Quikscell Company]] he is added on the vehicle page, you go to it and found the vehicle is produced on [[Ares (planet)|Ares]], you hit the Ares link then you come to the planet page and se Ares is a Capellan Confederation planet and was produced on it, i don't want merged content on the 'Mech, Combat Vehicle sites that don't follow the Project Template. Neuling have good ideas but the problem is, he don't follow any policy, project or ref. policies and follow the right formating, take a look on [[Wars of Reaving - Timeline]], iam really sadly to say this, i don't fix or correct any contributions that he provide in next or future time, iam to tired, i talke to often to the problem, he is as a long time contributor (circa 1-2 year) on sarna and don't follow anything, this is my opinion, please talk to me when iam wrong.--[[User:Doneve|Doneve]] 01:16, 4 December 2011 (UTC) | ||
| − | : Neuling - Respectfully, some of your changes might be more agreeable if they were "cleaner". Specifically, if there weren't so many typos. Both Doneve and I have had to cleanup the [[ | + | : Neuling - Respectfully, some of your changes might be more agreeable if they were "cleaner". Specifically, if there weren't so many typos. Both Doneve and I have had to cleanup the [[Lightning]]. Thanks. [[User:ClanWolverine101|ClanWolverine101]] 07:39, 5 December 2011 (UTC) |
===MechWarrior Online=== | ===MechWarrior Online=== | ||